Bilingual Asian children do better
November 25, 2003
By Dominic Casciani, Online community affairs reporter
Children who study the language and culture of their immigrant parents may
achieve more and become more involved citizens, according to research.
A pilot study of 5,000 children attending community classes in Leicester
suggests the ad hoc system strengthens communities and reinforces the importance
of education in the minds of the young.
Complementary schools organised by immigrant communities try to ensure
British-born children retain a sense of their heritage.
But the findings of an initial study by Birmingham and Leicester universities
into Asian, Polish and Irish communities suggested the value to wider society
could be greater than appreciated.
In the study, the team looked at the experiences of children and adults
attending some 70 community-led classes in Leicester, one of the most ethnically
diverse cities in the UK.
The activities ranged from religious teaching for Hindus, Sikhs and Muslims, to
after-school homework groups emphasising languages such as India's Gujarati.
The team found that keeping up a language such as Gujarati, predominantly spoken
in the home, could improve a student's performance because it gave them a
greater understanding and more subtle use of language and communication.
Arvind Bhatt, one of the authors of the report, said they found benefits for the
student and the community which remained invisible to the majority of society.
"When a student properly learns and uses their mother tongue, they are also
learning how to manage bilingualism," said Mr Bhatt.
"This means being able to manage language in different contexts to their
Language and integration
The study's findings contradict last year's controversial comments on language
by the UK Home Secretary, David Blunkett.
He suggested British Asians should speak more English at home to "overcome the
schizophrenia which bedevils generational relationships".
But Mr Bhatt said: "David Blunkett's view was based on the false premise that
children can only learn one language at a time and learning a mother tongue
interferes with English.
"We found bilingualism in children was an asset in the long term, though there
is evidence it can cause some short-term difficulties."
Looking at how class participants saw themselves, the team found students had a
more settled sense of their own identity.
"Today's children want a flexible identity," said Mr Bhatt. "They don't want to
be pinned down as either Asian or British.
"They want to be able to negotiate these identities depending on the context
they find themselves in.
"This works to the benefit of their own position as citizens and the cohesion of
This settling of identity questions also helped close the generational gap
between now-elderly immigrants and their British-born descendents.
"What we tend to see is that the first generation keep their heads down and try
to survive and the second want to consolidate on what their parents achieved [in
having a stake in society]," said Mr Bhatt.
"We found evidence that the third generation uses complementary learning to
reclaim identity and heritage which brings the age groups together.
"We are now seeing members of the second generation - parents in their 30s -
going to the same complementary schooling as their children because they want to