Schwarzenegger Language-Advocacy Link Is
August 30, 2003
Greg Krikorian and Joe Mathews
The candidate for governor is called on to
sever ties with U.S. English. Some leaders of the group have been accused of
Arnold Schwarzenegger is coming under growing criticism from civil rights groups
and immigrants' advocates for his 16-year membership on the advisory board of
U.S. English, a Washington-based organization that bills itself as the nation's
largest group dedicated to preserving English as America's official language.
For much of Schwarzenegger's tenure on the board, U.S. English Inc. has been
dogged by accusations that the group's day-to-day leadership has used its
English-first message to hide a more racially divisive agenda.
Seizing on evidence of the group's ties to extremist groups, the country's
oldest Latino civil rights group — the League of United Latin American Citizens
— called on Schwarzenegger Thursday to quit the U.S. English board.
Other civil rights groups have followed suit, saying that they see a pattern of
antipathy to immigrants in Schwarzenegger's service with U.S. English; his
support of the 1994 ballot initiative Proposition 187, which would have cut off
public services to illegal immigrants in California; and his selection of that
proposition's key proponent, former Gov. Pete Wilson, as a campaign co-chairman.
The criticism has been fueled by recent allegations that U.S. English's
communications director had ties to white supremacists. Earlier this month, the
communications director resigned from U.S. English as did well-known
conservative columnist David Horowitz, who said his conscience would not allow
him to remain on the board.
"Schwarzenegger is disingenuous if he thinks that, by telling us he is
pro-immigrant and pro-Latino, the Hispanic community is going to vote for him,"
said national President Hector Flores of the Latino rights group. League
officials stressed that they have no position on recalling Gov. Gray Davis.
Antonio Gonzalez, president of the William C. Velasquez Institute, a Los
Angeles-based group that studies Latino political trends, said U.S. English
"represents the legitimate face of fascism in America And to think that
Schwarzenegger has been tied to them for 15 years is awful."
Schwarzenegger has not resigned and has not discussed his U.S. English ties in
public. A campaign spokesman, Sean Walsh, said that Schwarzenegger hadn't "been
active" with the board in several years and "does not track" U.S. English's
The movie star-turned-candidate does support the broad goal of encouraging
immigrants to learn English, Walsh said.
"He came as an immigrant to the country," Walsh said. "He did not speak the
language. He, like millions of other immigrants, realized very quick that if you
did not master or become proficient in the tongue of the country you immigrate
to, you will be severely impacted in enjoying all the fruits and freedoms."
If Schwarzenegger has been inactive he would hardly be the only board member to
be distant from the group. Harvard sociologist Nathan Glazer said this week that
he had been listed on the board for more than a decade "but the board and I have
been totally inactive for a dozen years."
"It was a question of having your name listed," Glazer said. A list of the
advisory board posted Friday on the U.S. English Web site includes novelist Saul
Bellow, golfing great Arnold Palmer, former Sen. Eugene McCarthy, actor Lee
Majors and game show host Alex Trebek.
The organization's chairman, a Chilean-born architect named Mauro Mujica, said
the organization's internal politics have nothing to do with Schwarzenegger or
California's recall election.
"It's a lot to do about nothing," Mujica said, saying that the group is neither
anti-Latino nor anti-immigrant. "It has only to do with the language issues and
the belief that immigrants who come to this country should learn the language of
The organization was formed four years before Schwarzenegger joined. A Michigan
ophthalmologist named John Tanton , who was worried that the nation's population
growth was destroying the environment, founded the group with S.I. Hayakawa, a
former Republican senator from California. Today, it claims 1.7 million members.
In 1987, Schwarzenegger joined the board, according to U.S. English. In 1988,
Schwarzenegger was a featured attraction at a membership meeting of the group at
the Biltmore Hotel in Los Angeles, according to U.S. English's then-director,
That same year, a provocative internal memo by Tanton on "the non-economic
consequences of immigration" was leaked to the press. The seven-page memo posed
questions such as "Is apartheid in Southern California's future?" and "Will
Latin American migrants bring with them the tradition of the mordida (bribe),
the lack of involvement in public affairs, etc.?"
Tanton's memo raised questions about the "reproductive powers" of the races,
suggesting: "perhaps this is the first instance in which those with the pants up
are going to get caught by those with their pants down!"
After the memo's release, Tanton was ousted from the group. But advisory board
member Walter Cronkite and director Chavez, a former Reagan administration
appointee, resigned from U.S. English.
"I kept hearing the group was anti-immigrant and anti-Hispanic and I would
defend it against those statements," recalled Chavez in an interview. "But when
the memo appeared, it was impossible for me to do that."
Cronkite, through a spokeswoman, said recently that he could no longer abide
U.S. English when it seemed to shift focus from language to immigration.
After the flap, Schwarzenegger remained on the group's advisory board. Chavez
said that, despite her resignation, she did not believe Schwarzenegger was
obliged to cut ties with the organization.
"I wouldn't use his being on the board of U.S. English as any evidence that he
harbors anti-immigrant views," Chavez said.
Earlier this month, Mujica accepted the resignation of his communications
director, James Lubinskas, after the Southern Poverty Law Center linked
Lubinskas with white extremists.
Mark Potok, editor of the Southern Poverty Law Center's quarterly "Intelligence
Report," said Lubinskas shared the podium at Washington, D.C., conferences in
1999 and 2000 with former Ku Klux Klan members David Duke and Don Black. In
addition, Potok said, Lubinskas wrote as recently as this spring for a journal
run by white supremacist Jared Taylor.
Lubinskas declined to comment.
"U.S. English is part of a much broader movement that is, at its roots,
xenophobic, exclusionary and divisive," said Rick Swartz, who founded the
advocacy group National Immigration Forum in 1982. "And any candidate for office
who over time has been a part of such a movement, I think, deserves deep