Indians say English-only policy
diminishes their tribal languages
Mar. 14, 2007
By Tim Talley
OKLAHOMA CITY - Legislation to make English the state's official language
has run into opposition from American Indians, who say their native tongues
are dying fast enough without any help from lawmakers.
As Oklahoma observes its centennial year, the English-only issue points up
divisions that persist more than a century after Indians were forcibly
marched to the region and then endured a series of land grabs.
Many of Oklahoma's 37 federally recognized tribes are fighting to save their
languages and cultures from extinction years after the end of organized
efforts to stamp them out.
Critics of the English-only Legislation point out that Oklahoma's very name
is formed from two Choctaw Indian words - "okla" and "homma" - that mean
"If you go to English only, what are we going to call the state of
Oklahoma?" said Terry Ragan, director of the Choctaw Nation's language
program. "Even town names in the state will have to be named differently."
Supporters of the legislation say it could end bilingual state government
documents, such as driver's license tests, and force immigrants to learn
English and assimilate into American society.
English-only legislation has been adopted in 28 states and measures are
pending in 12 states, said Rob Toonkel, director of communications for U.S.
English, Inc. of Washington, D.C., an interest-group that supports making
English the nation's official language. A similar measure has been filed in
The national English-only movement does not want to deprive American Indians
of their native languages but is aimed at standardizing government documents
into a single language as a symbol of unity for immigrant populations,
"It's very much an assimilation issue," he said. "We should make sure they
become part of the country."
But assimilation is a charged word for many American Indians, whose
ancestors were forced from their traditional lands and sent on the Trail of
Tears in the 19th century.
English-only restrictions were imposed in Indian Territory to expunge tribal
languages and culture, said Kirke Kickingbird, an Oklahoma City attorney and
member of the Kiowa tribe.
"That whole era was really about assimilation," he said.
Chad Smith, chief of the 250,000-member Cherokee Nation, the largest
American Indian tribe in the United States, said the state's image is harmed
when cultural differences are not embraced.
"There's a message sent to those outside of Oklahoma that we're intolerant,
we're colloquial and we want to isolate ourselves from the rest of the
world," Smith said.
"To our tribes it says that if there's an official language, your language
is secondary and all other languages are secondary," said Smith, who has
also criticized athletic teams using Indian mascots and names.
Supporters point out that the legislation doesn't interfere with the
teaching or learning of American Indian languages. But critics said a
government policy could impede efforts to revive tribal languages.
The Intertribal Wordpath Society, a nonprofit group based in Norman,
estimates that only about 9,000 people are fluent in the Cherokee language
and 4,000 in the Choctaw language.
Fewer than a dozen people are fluent in other American Indian languages,
including those of the Osage, Pawnee and Chiricahua Apache tribes, according
to the group.
"We have absolutely nothing against English. It's great if people speak
English," said Alice Anderton, a former linguist at the University of
Oklahoma and executive director of the Intertribal Wordpath Society. "But
it's great if people speak English plus some other language of heritage."
On the Net:
Intertribal Wordpath Society: http://www.ahalenia.com/iws