THIRD-GRADERS' SUCCESS WILL DECIDE THEIR SCHOOL'S FUTURE
April 1, 2007
Author: Karina Bland
Estimated printed pages: 8
CREIGHTON STUDENTS MAKE BIG STRIDES BUT ARE STILL SHORT OF GOAL. AGAIN.
Like many third-graders at Creighton Elementary School in Phoenix, 9-year-old
Oscar Medina thinks that if he doesn't pass the state's AIMS test, he won't get
to go to fourth grade next year.
That's not true, his teacher assures him. What Oscar doesn't realize is that
it's not fourth grade but the fate of his school that rests on his and his
By federal standards, schools are required to make adequate yearly progress or
face government intervention. For four years, Creighton hasn't met the standards
under the No Child Left Behind law.
If enough of this year's third-graders don't do well on Arizona's Instrument to
Measure Standards, or AIMS, a fifth year without adequate progress calls for
restructuring and possible state takeover and a new principal.
Rosemary Agneessens smiles wryly at the thought. It's a stressful job, with long
She pores over spreadsheets of reading scores. Her students, who speak mostly
Spanish, do fine in math because it doesn't require they read in English.
Agneessens takes off her glasses, rubs her eyes and says, "I just want them to
read. Not only for AIMS but because if they don't learn now, they may never
Almost three years ago, The Arizona Republic began chronicling the efforts of a
group of children at Creighton as they began to learn to read.
Many started first grade without even knowing the alphabet. Now, nearing the end
of third grade, they have made tremendous progress, with some kids jumping two
grade levels in reading this year alone.
Still, the children don't read as well as they should by now. In December, about
25 percent of the 110 third-graders tested as proficient in reading.
Their struggles mirror those of children across Arizona, where 24 percent of
fourth-graders are proficient in reading, compared with 31 percent nationally.
There are other schools in Creighton's position, most of them in low-income
There is a determined air about Creighton. Students in all other grades are
poised to pass AIMS, based on ongoing assessments. Lynne Spiller, the district's
director of research and evaluation, thinks the third-graders could possibly
pass, just maybe, what with the school's new reading program and additional
Testing starts April 9, though the results won't be available until after school
lets out in May. Everyone, from district officials and the school board to the
state superintendent of public instruction and federal government, will be
Oscar has been practicing for AIMS, reading to his mother every night at the
kitchen table. "I'm ready," he says.
New language, big barrier
On third-grade teacher Emaretta Hines' desk is a copy of How to Eat Fried Worms
by Thomas Rockwell. Her students aren't ready to read it for themselves yet, so
she's reading it to them.
The majority of her students still are learning English. A few started the
school year speaking no English at all. Now they're reading aloud and using
sophisticated words in their writing, such as "awesome" and "discovered,"
copied carefully from a vocabulary list.
Eight-year-old Rosario Portillo has jumped two grade levels in reading, though
she is still about a year behind where she should be for her age.
"That's significant growth," says Karen Tankersley, a reading consultant and
Arizona State University West professor. If she and other students could show
the same kind of growth next year, they would be right where they need to be in
reading. Even better, if they went to summer school, they could be on grade
level by the time they start fourth grade.
But Rosario and her classmates will take AIMS long before that, and the person
scoring her test can't take into account that she moved here from Mexico in
State education officials expect children to learn English in one year, though
most research shows that the English skills needed to perform well academically
can take five to seven years to master.
Creighton's inability to make adequate yearly progress rests on its
English-learners. The school is a first stop for many immigrants, with student
turnover as high as 50 percent.
Creighton third-graders are in one of two programs: English immersion, where
subjects are taught entirely in English; or dual-language, where students also
receive instruction in Spanish.
In dual-language, Oscar has made up the ground he lost as he struggled to learn
English because he gets half of his instruction in Spanish. He has jumped a
grade level and a half in reading and now hovers just below grade level.
Arizona law doesn't allow bilingual education. However, schools can offer
dual-language classes if students already are proficient in English. It took
until third grade for Oscar and many of his classmates to get fluent enough in
English to qualify. AIMS is in English.
Still, the strongest predictor of school success is a child's socioeconomic
status, says Jeff MacSwan, associate professor of education at Arizona State
University in Tempe and author of several reports on Arizona's English-learners.
Children with richer parents fare better in school than poor kids. At Creighton,
90 percent of students qualify for federal reduced-price and free meal programs.
Coupled with the fact that they are learning English, he says, "It does stand to
reason that if these kids are working in both languages, they are going to trail
behind a bit. A year is not a big deal. They're going to be able to catch up."
But maybe not in time to pass this year's AIMS test.
Getting ready for AIMS
In a sense, third-graders at Creighton, like kids their age across the state,
have been preparing for AIMS since the start of the school year. All children
take the AIMS test for the first time in third-grade.
They've been pushed to read independently instead of relying on a reading buddy
or a teacher as they did in second grade. They'll have to read on their own for
AIMS and, by the fourth grade, they're expected to get as much information from
textbooks as they do from their teachers.
Their teachers have taught them test-taking strategies, such as highlighting
passages to pick out key ideas and what to do when they come across an
They use dictionaries now instead of asking their teachers how to spell a word
or what it means. (Students can use dictionaries during AIMS.)
Third-graders are forced to grow up as scholars, getting little slack for
forgotten homework or misplaced assignments. It's a time of great growth, with
kids snapping up new words and concepts.
Oscar pulls his sweatshirt off over his head and tucks his white-collared
uniform shirt back into his navy trousers. He and his seatmates are talking
about the characters, setting and conflict of the book Dogzilla by Dav Pilkey.
They'll likely be asked to do the same on AIMS. The test measures state
standards in reading, writing and math.
One recent afternoon, third-graders worked on antonyms and synonyms during a new
intervention started this year called "Reading Plus." All Creighton students get
an extra 45 minutes of reading instruction, grouped by ability and in small
Last year, the same approach to teaching math resulted in significant gains.
Fifty-seven percent of Creighton third-graders passed the math portion of AIMS
in 2004-05, up from 18 percent in 2003-04 and even better than the statewide
rate of 43 percent.
By teaching in small groups, teachers can target instruction to each child's
weakness. Children who catch on quickly can move up, from group to group, as
their skills improve.
With their teachers doing everything to prepare them for AIMS and the rigors of
fourth grade, Principal Agneessens turned to their parents for help.
In a series of meetings all year, she has met with parents in every grade level
to talk about their children's progress.
"We're doing everything we can here at school," she told them in Spanish. If
their children are to succeed, they must help them at home.
"This is serious," Agneessens said. "The success of your children depends on
what you do at home."
Some parents cried.
Kids are reason to hope
Now Oscar reads to his mother after he finishes his homework. His classmate,
Diego Covarrubias, reads to his big sister.
In Hines' class, Rosario and 8-year-old Melissa Viera stay after school to help
Hines tidy the room. They like being at school so much, they're reluctant to
Melissa reads aloud, "Where is the circle? The circle is over the square.
Where is the oval? The oval fell off the triangle. Oops." The girls giggle.
The children's efforts are reason for hope. These third-graders entered
kindergarten just as a wave of reading reforms were being integrated into
classrooms, not only at their own school but also across the country.
The new reading program this year has meant an additional 45 minutes of
instruction every day, and children get additional tutoring in the areas where
they are weak.
And more third-graders this year were proficient enough in English to qualify
for the school's dual-language program, and their reading has improved
dramatically compared with the third-graders in English-immersion classes.
"I have the greatest hope that it will be enough," says Spiller, the district's
research and evaluation director. She monitors students' progress through
Third-graders have shown progress since December, and she hopes it will be
enough. At least 61 percent of third-graders must test proficient in reading or
the school again won't meet its federal progress requirements.
If only they had a little more time, Spiller says, they would be sure to make
it. About 70 percent of fourth-graders are on track to pass AIMS.
"Once they figure out the language, they shoot up," Spiller says.
Test time is growing near.
"The students know they have a big test coming up," says Jessica Barrios,
Oscar's teacher in the dual-language program.
She has assured them that AIMS won't determine if they go to fourth-grade.
But they have to pass AIMS to graduate from high school, so they may as well
She has high expectations for her students, assigning them to reading groups
named after colleges: New York University, Arizona State, University of
Down the breezeway, Hines explains to her students that AIMS will measure what
they know compared with what they are supposed to know. There is no reason to
tell them what hinges on their scores.
They've worked hard all year. "Just do your very best," Hines tells them.
8 WAYS PARENTS CAN HELP
All children take Arizona's Instrument to Measure Standards, or AIMS test, for
the first time in third grade. Teachers are doing what they can to get them
ready. Before your children sharpen their No. 2 pencils, here is what you can do
Make sure your children are at school every day unless they're sick. "They can't
learn if they're not here," says Rosemary Agneessens, principal of Creighton
Elementary School in Phoenix.
If you see your children struggling as they work on their homework, encourage
them to ask their teacher for help. Or call the teacher yourself, explain the
situation and ask what you can do at home to help.
Keep tabs on your children's homework and make sure it gets done. Students need
practice to get better.
Encourage reading, particularly
non-fiction, which often appears on standardized tests. Ask questions to ensure
they understand what they are reading: What is the main idea? How was the
problem resolved? Ask them to express their own ideas or opinions about what
Encourage your children to decipher difficult words on their own. Don't just
provide the answer. Also, practice using the dictionary at home to look up words
to double-check spellings and learn their meanings.
Make math a part of every day, asking children how many tortillas you'll need to
buy if everyone in the family eats two or what time you should leave the house
to get to Grandma's house by 5:30 if it takes 20 minutes to get there.
To prepare for testing days, make sure kids are physically ready. Put them to
bed a little early the night before and serve a healthy breakfast.
Practice relaxation techniques, such as counting from one to 10 or taking deep
breaths, if you think your children may be nervous on test day.
"We're doing everything we can," Agneessens says. "We need Mom and Dad to do
Includes information from the Arizona Department of Education and Scholastic
Inc. in New York.
About 1-2-3 Read
In 2004, The Arizona Republic pledged $120,000 to Phoenix's Creighton
Elementary School in hopes of raising reading scores. Over three years the
grants have paid for reading specialists, books and teacher training, among
other things. Volunteers from the newspaper also have tutored students.
The goal of the 1-2-3 Read project is to get the kids reading at third-grade
level by the end of their third-grade year. If the extra money and attention
make a difference, maybe the tactics could work at other schools.
About the series: The Arizona Republic's 1-2-3 Read partnership with
Creighton Elementary School.
CAPTION: 1) Oscar Medina (right), a third-grader at Creighton Elementary
School in Phoenix, has been practicing for the state's AIMS test. If too few
of his classmates do well, the school will have failed to meet federal
standards and might be taken over. 2) Third-graders Hernan Hernandez (left)
and Irvin Moreno read in their classroom at Creighton. 3) Jessica Barrios
works with third-grader Oscar Medina at Creighton Elementary in Phoenix. A
teacher in the dual-language program, she assigns students to reading groups
named after colleges. At least 61 percent of the school's third-graders must
test proficient in reading or Creighton again will fail to meet federal
standards. 4) Creighton students Luis Alia (from left), Jose Felix and
Hernan Hernandez prepare for Arizona's Instrument to Measure Standards. All
children first take the AIMS test in third grade. Testing starts April 9.
Edition: Final Chaser