U.S. education official touts English requirements
April 3, 2007
The nations top education official said schools with high concentrations of
Spanish speakers should not be exempted from federal English requirements.
"Most of our English-language-learner students are born here," Spellings said
Monday after visiting a Mesa charter school. "I don't think it's unreasonable
that by the end of the third grade they would be able to read on grade level in
Spellings toured the Mesa Arts Academy to promote the reauthorization of
President Bush's No Child Left Behind Act. The 2001 education reform law has
forced schools around the country to focus more on high stakes, standardized
tests. "We passed the very best law we could five years ago, and now we can
improve it based upon what we've learned," Spellings said.
Spellings did not meet with state Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Horne
during her visit.
Horne has called No Child Left Behind "erratic" and has charged that it sets
schools with high Spanish-speaking populations up to fail because it requires
immigrant children to be proficient in English after spending just one year in
Susan Carlson, executive director of the Arizona Business and Education
Coalition, said she supports the law but shares some of Horne's concerns.
"Arizona is unique among the states in that we have a continual influx of
English language learners," Carlson said. "Other states can take three years to
test their students in Spanish or the native language, but our state law
requires they are tested in English. That puts Arizona in kind of a losing
During her tour, Spellings praised the charter school for posting high test
scores even though many of its students come from low-income backgrounds, and
more than half the students come to the school speaking no English.
Spellings said the school is an example of the benefits of No Child Left Behind.
The law was touted as a way to ensure that minority children and those with
low-income backgrounds achieved at the same level as their wealthier