BASIS CHARTER SCHOOLS MAY OFFER THE BEST FREE EDUCATION IN
THE U.S. BUT APPLYING THE FORMULA TO PUBLIC SCHOOLS MAY NOT WORK, FOUNDERS SAY.
- CHARTER SCHOOL IS ALONE IN ITS CLASS
November 22, 2006
Author: Pat Kossan, The Arizona Republic Estimated printed pages: 7
No schools in Arizona have achieved the kind of national status that Basis
charter schools have.
In May, Newsweek magazine named Basis School Inc.'s high school in Tucson the
third-best in the country.
Earlier this month, Intel Corp. Chairman Craig Barrett and his wife, Barbara,
donated $450,000 to Basis Scottsdale middle school, citing its excellence.
In a state worried about its educational quality, Basis School Inc. should be a
But can Basis be replicated in other public schools? A close look at the
560-student system indicates that the proposition would be difficult at best.
Even its founders concur.
Basis' relentlessly rigorous curriculum inspires parents and leaders and could
set a standard for how to educate intelligent, motivated students. But it
doesn't live with the same academic challenges that most other public schools
Like those schools, Basis' high school and two middle schools are funded mostly
with state and federal money. It must accept any student who applies if there is
space, and its students must master state standards and pass the AIMS exit exam.
The similarities end there.
Basis offers few of the typical public-school extras, such as football or
cheerleading. It strives to winnow students to only the high achievers:
Beginning in sixth grade, it gives kids a final test and holds them back if they
fail twice. (Any public school can do this, but it's rare, state officials say.)
Most of its students are ambitious children of engineers, attorneys and doctors,
kids willing to hammer through math, science, history and literature courses
years beyond their academic peers.
Only 10 percent of its students are minorities. None is an English-language
learner. Few are low-income or have special-education needs.
What Basis offers is a free stripped-down elite education inside bland
commercial buildings. It has the complexion and tenor of the best private
schools but paid for with taxpayer money.
"We do for middle-class kids what public schools are designed to do:
transform their lives," said retired Professor Michael Block, who opened Basis
with his wife, Olga, in 1998. "We don't solve all problems. We do a certain
thing. We do it well."
Weeding out slackers
Basis schools scare away slackers by insisting that potential students shadow a
current student for a day.
The school weeds out the academically weak in the first few years of middle
"The magic bullet to this whole thing is the middle school," Michael said.
Teachers begin in fifth and sixth grade to prepare 11-year-olds to take on
pre-algebra and the first of three years each of chemistry, biology and physics.
By the end of eighth grade, students are ready for pre-calculus.
If they stumble along the way, though, they are out.
Each child must pass a comprehensive exam in sixth, seventh and eighth grades.
If the child doesn't pass after two attempts, he or she must repeat the grade or
One afternoon a few years ago, a sixth-grader who failed her comprehensive exam
walked into Olga's office and asked, "Do you have the legal right to fail me?"
"Yes, baby, I do," Olga recalls saying. "If you don't like the rules, please
Olga concedes some children are not ready to be serious students and work 10
hours a day. They need not apply. "I want to give this space to workaholics,"
The school loses 10 percent of its students by seventh grade. After eighth
grade, the school loses an additional 40 percent of its Tucson students who
decide against attending the Basis high school.
Those who make it to junior year will have completed two years of calculus and
taken Advanced Placement exams in a minimum of six subjects. They already have a
transcript most colleges would accept.
This rapid acceleration through tough courses makes it nearly impossible for
children to successfully transfer into Basis schools after the fifth or sixth
grades. Most can't catch up.
Olga Block's fierce view of academics grew from her hard-line schooling under a
communist regime, where she also worked as a university professor and dean.
Ten years ago, she moved from what is now the Czech Republic to marry Michael,
then a University of Arizona economics professor.
The couple incorporated the non-profit Basis School Inc. in 1998.
Opening the Tucson school in her new American home only intensified her
estrangement from the U.S. education system.
"It was also a frightening thing to me that the first question parents asked me
was, 'Would we have a music band?' I have a math program. I have a physics
program. I have a calculus program. What is this about a music band?"
Olga didn't try adjusting to the American classroom. Parents, students and
teachers adjust to her.
She relented a bit and added music to her curriculum, but she turned her gym
into a theater. Sports are an afterthought. Getting Tucson parents to fall in
line with her no-nonsense learning philosophy was easy compared with the "helicopterish"
parents who greeted her when she opened her Scottsdale middle school in 2003.
"It took me some time to overcome this whole problem (with parents): 'We studied
for this test the whole night, and we only received a B.' Basically, the first
year in Scottsdale, what we were doing was developing strategies of how to keep
Parents organize fund-raisers and dances, but they are asked to leave homework
for their children to complete and leave lesson plans and teacher hiring to the
"We're really good at what we do," Michael said. "We don't need parents to
become active participants."
In the end, the Blocks admit their contrary notions would not work in most
"This is not possible to run a school like this in the public system," Olga
"This is a very, very particular school," Michael added. "It's partially an
Teachers and kids
Basis builds schools for particular children who say they are thrilled to learn
the periodic table and pre-calculus in middle school.
"Everyone here knows they are geeks and nerds, and we're into it," said Amal
Elhag, a 16-year-old senior at Basis in Tucson.
Few of those geeks are Latino, African-American or Native American, though 7
percent are Asian-American. Michael said he does not recruit students to broaden
the schools' population.
"Legally, we take anyone," he said. "We certainly don't discriminate, so it's a
matter of what parents seek us out."
The Blocks recruit teachers from across the country. Most have master's or
doctoral degrees in the subjects they teach. Their average salary is about
$40,000, similar to the statewide average.
Before Basis, Ali Renner taught physics at an ivy-walled private school outside
Boston. She is teaching the same material to her Basis Tucson seventh-graders
that she taught her high school freshmen in Boston.
"Every now and then, I step back and I look at what I'm doing with these kids,"
Renner said. "And I can't believe it."
Like many Basis teachers, Renner said she would not teach in a regular district
or another charter school. She relishes her freedom to create her own lesson
plans and tests.
Basis teachers receive a bonus and keep their jobs if their students succeed,
which means passing comprehensive and state exams and classes. If too many
students fail, their contract isn't renewed.
But students are eager to learn. Unlike at most schools, learning gaps among
kids are minimal, history teacher Mark Zellmer said.
"I don't want to be in an environment where I had all that different range,"
Zellmer said. "I know that sounds snotty, but I don't want to deal with
"There is a need for a school that acts like a private school but is funded
publicly. That's what I think this does."
Parents will tell you students do not have to be gifted to survive in Basis
schools; they only have to be driven.
Parent Susan Price said it only makes sense to put her children in a school
where their hard work will get them ahead of other achievers.
Once a child demonstrates a willingness to work hard, teachers do everything
they can to make sure the child succeeds, said Lisa Rhodenbaugh, who has three
children in Basis.
That is a great help to this mother of eight children, who is home-schooling her
four youngest and can't devote hours to each child every day.
She thinks her boys are happier because the school now has more students and
parents understand what kind of school it is.
"My boys have a fantastic social network," Rhodenbaugh said of her sons'
friends. "They're from good families who are all about academics."
Ranked Arizona schools
Basis charter and three other schools made the top 1,200 in Newsweek's annual
Rank School City
3 Basis charter Tucson
949 Catalina Foothills Tucson
1106 Chaparral Scottsdale
1169 North Canyon Phoenix
The nation's Top 5
Newsweeks' rankings list schools using a formula based on the number of Advanced
Placement and International Baccalaureate tests taken and the number of
Rank School City
1 Talented & Gifted Dallas
2 Jefferson County IBS Irondale, Ala.
3 Basis charter Tucson
4 City Honors Buffalo, N.Y.
5 Stanton College Prep Jacksonville, Fla.
Basis School Inc.
WHAT IT IS
A not-for-profit charter-school company that runs two public middle schools and
one public high school offering accelerated curriculums.
* Basis Tucson Middle School, 3825 E. Second St.
* Basis Tucson High School, 3434 E. Broadway Blvd.
* Basis Scottsdale Middle School, 9128 E. San Salvador Drive.
560 students at three schools.
Native American: 1.
Special education: 16.
Low income: Few or none.
English-language learners: 0.
AIMS TEST SCORES
Percent passing 2005-06 exam:
Scottsdale fifth-graders: 98.
Scottsdale eighth-graders: 97.
Tucson eighth-graders: 100.
Tucson 10th-graders: 100.
Scottsdale fifth-graders: 100.
Scottsdale eighth-graders: 100.
Tucson eighth-graders: 99.
Tucson 10th-graders: 100.
DID YOU KNOW?
Owners Michael and Olga Block tried to open a private high school last year in
Scottsdale, with tuition of $7,000 a year. Seven kids showed up, and it closed
the same year. The Blocks are planning to open a public charter high school in
Scottsdale next school year.
Sources: Arizona Department of Education, Basis School Inc.
Reach the reporter at firstname.lastname@example.org.
CAPTION: 1) Ninth-graders Lark Yildirim (left), Grainne Griffiths and Alexandra
Birch study during their lunch break at a Basis charter school in Tucson. The
curriculum is grueling at the school. 2) Olga and Michael Block founded Basis
School Inc. in 1998 and have created some of the best schools in the nation,
including the Basis charter school in Tucson.
Edition: Final Chaser
Copyright (c) The Arizona Republic. All rights reserved. Reproduced with the
permission of Gannett Co., Inc. by NewsBank, inc.
Record Number: pho158546178
OpenURL Article Bookmark (right click, and copy the link location):
BASIS CHARTER SCHOOLS MAY OFFER THE BEST FREE EDUCATION IN THE U.S. BUT
APPLYING THE FORMULA TO PUBLIC SCHOOLS MAY NOT WORK, FOUNDERS SAY.